Mom Talk – Part 14

Question: What didn’t I ask you that you would have thought I would have asked? What didn’t you get a chance to say?

What questions didn’t I ask? A dozen that I can think of. Hundreds that are waiting in the deep recesses of my brain to be thought of. For the time being, read on.

Answers:

1. No I think you got everything.

2. I think you covered everything.

3. I would have thought you would have asked me about advice I would give to certain people on certain things. I think that’s really interesting to hear people’s advice because everyone comes from such different backgrounds and different marriages and different kids. There’s so many elements between, you know, the relationship with the spouse or work or all these different things. The balance. I think a big topic of conversation, especially in my world, is the juggle— the balance— work/life balance. That topic comes up almost every day in my life with people. So talking about how motherhood affects work, how you identify yourself— your own identity and how motherhood affects that. Most people have had kids in their late 20s or 30s so you have worked— you’ve built some career— how children affect that. Something that you identified with for so long, that you’ve worked so hard for, and how motherhood affects that. That to me is a very big topic of conversation that should always be addressed because it does affect it for anyone who had kids a little bit later.

Unfortunately today, it’s 2019, you have to accept the fact that it ain’t fair. It’s just not fair. It’s all gonna fall on you. The men cannot have the babies. You have to have the baby—that’s just how it is. You have to be pregnant, you have to have the baby, you have to recover from it. You’re in charge of that and no one can change a damn thing about it and you have to accept the fact that it’s basically like working while you are sick: you are not at 100% during that pregnancy— you’re just not— and you’re certainly not at 100% after the pregnancy and your priorities change and things change and things shift but that doesn’t mean it’s the end of the road. It doesn’t mean its the end of your career. Careers don’t have to be linear. There are options out there if you want to switch gear or you want to take your career down a few notches there are options. You just have to explore them. It’s not all or nothing anymore.

And here’s the other thing I like to talk about because people don’t talk about it enough— and some people will get mad at me for saying this but not many. My opinion, and I think the opinion of many other people, is that you cannot be a great CEO, a great mother, a great friend and a great wife all at the same time; I just don’t believe that. Something’s gotta give. So if you’re the CEO— and that’s an extreme— any sort of big, big major job that’s very demanding and very prestigious— there’s no way you’re also the best mom in the world. I’m sorry, you have to travel. You can be a loving mother but you’re certainly not the most hands-on because it’s impossible. Oh wait and there’s a spouse too. And that person needs your love and attention and a date night and, you know, compassion; and he’s had quite a day also. Unless he’s the stay-at-home dad and that’s another dynamic. But the point is you can’t be it all so something’s gotta give and you have to make choices sometimes and when you have small children, which one’s gonna give? Oh wait and then your girlfriends want to hang out too and you don’t want to lose those friendships so there’s all these things pulling at you. So for people who think you can lean in and have it all, I honestly think it’s bullshit. I don’t believe that at all. Sorry, I know that book sold a lot of copies. I’m sorry. That only works for a very narrow kind of person. I’ve been in the corporate world for a long time. I have my own business; I know what’s what. The women who are in their 40s in big time jobs— they are not the same types of mothers that they want to be. They feel guilty all the time. There’s only so many hours of the day. Oh wait and you have to also throw in self-care like working out. But it’s all a balance. People constantly ask me— I don’t know why they ask me this— it’s really interesting, “are you working, like, part time?” I’m like, I have a full time business; this isn’t a hobby— it’s full time. But it’s my version of full time and the hours are spread out. My older son’s last day of school is on Tuesday and I want to be there to pick him up and that’s in the middle of the day. So I blocked out three hours of time in the middle of the day but I’ll catch up either that night after he goes to sleep or I’ll catch up the next day.

I don’t want the time to pass and I don’t want the day to come where I look back and it is too late. I never wanted to regret not trying to create something, to create a legacy, to create something that has meaning and that has meaning to me.

Not everyone feels this way; this is just me. I always say to my friends who are stay-at-home moms: I wish I wanted to be a stay-at-home mom because I have the privilege, if I wanted, to be a stay-at-home mom— to be able to do that— and I don’t want to be. I sometimes feel guilty because I don’t want to be but at the same time I don’t feel guilty. As it is now, the time I have with my kids I enjoy because I appreciate it. Because I have other things going on and I work. But I think if I were a stay-at-home mom I would not feel as appreciative of the time I have with them and I don’t think my marriage would be as strong. And eventually, by the way, they go to school and then eventually they leave and then what? That was always my fear – that time will come so fast and then what am I doing? Then what am I doing with myself? So. I think this is a common conversation that people have. Men don’t have to have these conversations, but women do.

4. What might be interesting for a book like this is to talk about how motherhood might maybe affect professional life or career development. Maybe not?

5. I don’t think there’s anything else I was thinking you would ask. I really didn’t know what we were doing. Is that okay? Anything else? I feel like once this baby comes I could have a lot more things to say. I mean I just hope it’s healthy. But if it’s not it would be a whole other chapter of my book.

6. Do I like my kids? No I’m kidding. How do I— maybe not every mother feels like they need to escape motherhood— but how do I escape motherhood when I need to? Because I definitely need to. And that is just hiding somewhere. Going to yoga. And also I would say, you know, how has my husband’s approach at being a father affected my approach at being a mother? I think there’s a misconception sometimes that men don’t pull their fair share and that’s a very antiquated concept I feel like. I think it was true in the Baby Boomer generation. I think this generation of dads, at least from what I’ve seen, but personally and around me, dads are really pulling their weight at home. And I think thinking about being a parent when I was young versus what that has turned into now, it really is a team effort.

It’s funny. It’s more so about women’s natural ability to organize and prioritize maybe. That was one of the biggest points of contention between my husband and me when we first had kids it was— from the Break Up— “I don’t need you to do the dishes; I need you to want to do the dishes.” We want not only the physical labor to be unburdened but we want the mental labor that’s required to do all these things like the Christmas cards or— we have not yet sent out the we’ve moved cards— or the medical forms for camp and little things that get piled up. I’m trying to shift it in that direction but also, and I think about this too: when we first started living together I had a condo and I just didn’t want to be a landlord anymore so I moved out of my condo and we rented it out and I was like, yeah I want nothing to do with this. Here you go. And now he handles that and he handles all of the finances and he handles all of the, you know, when we are finally ready to sell our house he’s going to do all of it. So I forgive him a little bit. I also understand that he’s got his own other things that he’s worried about that he’s better suited to do. So if I have to tell him sometimes, “hey, you have to clean out the garage” it’s fine. But it is a little frustrating because I’m like can’t you just read my mind? Just read my mind. Just get it from in there please.

If I say to my husband, “I’m going to hot yoga and you can’t stop me like, bye, peace out—” I used to worry about well what is he going to do with the kids? Is he going to feed them? And I’ve gotten to the point where— well the kids have gotten a little older and they can say what they want— but like I just go. In fact I just go a lot. When it’s my mom or my husband’s mom or my husband I’m like: figure it out. If they’re hungry, they’ll tell you. Just give them some water. Just make sure they don’t dehydrate and we’re good. So I’m a little less neurotic about micromanaging their things. My mom is not. So funny story. My mom had something where she couldn’t be with us for a week so my husband’s mom stayed with us for a week and got them off to school. My mother made a list: “She will only eat x, y and z” and she made a whole list. And do you know what I did when she left? I threw it in the garbage. And I’m like to my mother-in-law: you got this. I’m sure you’ll know what to make them for lunch. If they don’t like it, they won’t eat it and they’ll eat when they come home.

It was fine; everyone was fine. The funny thing about my mom— she spends every single day with the girls but they like what they like because she manages it for them but my husband’s mom has a completely different way of doing it and she does different things and I can’t let my mom impose on her or me. Because my mom’ll tell me, “this one doesn’t like x, y, z” and I’m like, really? Well she’s gonna eat it or she’s gonna starve. So that’s been interesting. People will figure it out. I said to somebody because we were having a conversation about are we going to hold a kid back? I will face that challenge or that decision with my younger daughter because she was born in September. “Are you gonna hold her back?” “I don’t know, I guess I’ll see when I get there.” “Because there have been studies done about x, y, z” and I’m like, our kids will be fine just by virtue of the fact that they’re our kids; we care— we care so much— and this decision— even if it turns out she has a bad time in second grade because of something— I’m not going to go back and be like it’s because I didn’t send her early or late or whatever. They’re gonna be fine.

The other thing I’ll tell you I think is funny. I was talking to a cousin of mine. Long story short, she was very coddled by her parents when she was little and she and I are the same age. It sucks but she went through a rough time. She got married to someone she shouldn’t have gotten married to, he left her, she was like depressed for a long time, she went through bouts and bouts of depression and now she blames her mom because her mom always coddled her. And I’m like— all of our parents did the best they could; they all did what was right. You can’t have resentment towards her because she didn’t let you fail or didn’t let you do this. Now you’ve gotta get over it because you’re 38. But I did say my mom was always very self-centered when she was young. This is a new mom that I have now; she’s amazing to her grandkids. To me and my sister she was kind of never present. Not that I’m throwing her under the bus or anything. She was cool and she was strict but she was not present all the time. My dad did a lot of the parenting, a lot of the cooking at home. But I said to my cousin: you know, there’s something to be said for a little bit of neglect. We can’t go and micromanage our kids lives. If my older daughter gets a teacher that’s not highly regarded I’m not gonna go in and fight for her to get the right teacher because you know what? It might do her some good. A little neglect goes a long way. And I hate to say it that way— it sounds so dismissive, but kids’ll figure it out. None of this is going to scar them for life. Everything will be fine.

Perfectionism was a childish— something childish I held onto for a long time. I still try to do things really well; I still bring my best. But that notion that I had to be perfect to other people is what I let go of. Always, all of this comes with forgiveness of myself. Am I always going to do the right thing? No. And I just have to be okay with that. I forgive myself for yelling. Like this morning. My older daughter is very rigid. She tried on three different outfits even after we picked an outfit last night to go gymnastics camp; she didn’t like it because it was a tad big. And I lost my mind and I yelled at her; we got into a huge fight and she was crying and it didn’t go well. Later I’ll apologize. But I didn’t handle that well. But then again we’re all trying to get ready in the morning and it’s gonna go crazy so I just have to forgive myself for it. Or, like, I work a lot and I travel a lot and I have my younger daughter that says, “Mommy, can you play with me?” And I can’t because I have to get on a conference call or I have to leave or I have to do something and we’re all just trying to do the best we can so I try to forgive myself often. And maybe that line about neglect is part of me just rationalizing that for myself, but I also do believe it. I do believe it. I hope this was helpful.

8. I love your questions. I really love them because I feel like I never had the time to reflect on this motherhood— never. You just have to keep going; you don’t even have time to think about it, to reflect on it. And really this should come back every once and awhile. I think you should go back to these women, to me, in 2 years because it will change and the story will only be better.

9. When are you most stressed? Or when do you feel like you’re lacking as a parent? Right? Some negative stuff. You asked a lot of positives. For me, when I feel like I can’t be there for them when I want to be there. Like last week was end of school stuff so you’re making a priority to be at the school event, the party, but it’s also the last day of gymnastics and there’s a parent thing that day and the last day of swimming also in that week and you just can’t make it all; that’s when I get really stressed out because it impacts them. And I see it.

So I pick the ones I can go to; I try to make sure my husband can go to something or the two of us are at the most important things together. Because it’s also hard when you go to an event and both parents are there and your spouse isn’t. And we just try to do our best.

Most dads in this town work, some moms don’t. So they expect that the dad won’t be there to all these things but they expect that the mom will be there. So I’m constantly reinforcing that you know: Mommy works. Mommy has a great job and it’s a good thing for Mom and for you and Mommy will always get to as much as she can get to. And it might not always be every time but I will make it my job to get to the most important things.

I’m so disappointed. A couple of weeks ago I couldn’t go to an event because of an important meeting and the meeting was just not important. And we walked away from it— I was just devastated. I was like, why did I waste my time with this? When I had my first child one of the ladies I worked with said, “every day you’re going to have to leave at the time when you think is right for you and other people won’t leave at that time. And you need to be okay with it and walk out the door with your head held high.” And I’ve very much stuck to it. But even today I leave for the 5:18 train and nobody else is leaving and I have to be okay with that. So part of it is just changing your anxieties and guilt and your feelings and perception of other people. Not caring. Because your kids are most important.

My sister once said to me when I was thinking about quitting, “you don’t have to not work; right now you have to work less. So you need to find the right situation where you can work less than what you were previously doing” and that’s hard. It’s like finding the right fit and the right job. And that can’t be both parents. Because somebody has to bring home the bacon. She also always said, “you’re never going to get to everything; you have to pick what’s most important.” so those are two rules I follow and like you said, just forgiving yourself. It’s hard. It’s so hard. It’s hard for everybody. If I were home it would be just as hard. I can step away from motherhood so much every day and be in my previous life and enjoy that, right? Like all the adult interactions and the brain work and everything. And I couldn’t do that if I were at home and that would be really hard on my mental strength.

10. Oh no! Not necessarily. I think they were great and I think it’s a great initiative for so many reasons. I think the whole celebrity culture thing— I don’t understand why people take advice— because they’re not living in the real world and you’re only seeing one side of how they do things. They could be a horrible mother. The picture doesn’t show them with all the other things that are going on in their lives it’s just a picture.

I guess other things that come up, I don’t know, I think we touched on a lot of good things. One thing I notice is that there are so many misconceptions that come up about motherhood. Some people think it’s so easy, you know, I have gotten a lot of that at work. You know, you can just do this assignment and it’s no problem and they don’t appreciate that I’ve done this assignment while there’s a kid screaming in the background and there’s this going on and craziness happening around me. There are people who don’t appreciate motherhood and it does always take me by surprise but it does exist and I think that that’s something that I have to learn to respond to or sometimes maybe just not engage with. I have seen things happen with moms being sort of shamed and that always makes me so uncomfortable. But there still is that undercurrent with women where there is a lot of mom-shaming that goes on. The kid is screaming in the restaurant and another person complains and says things like your kid is only cute to you. I’ve heard things like that. I think that’s so messed up. I just think there has to be more tolerance in general in the world. I think maybe it starts with— maybe that’s something mom culture can drive. Let’s be tolerant. Let’s understand there’s a lot of work that goes into being a mom and just appreciate and value them. Show some respect while you’re at it.

I’m so happy to be in the world of moms. I always wanted to go over to that side. And it’s like I do feel like now an automatic kinship with someone on the street who’s a mom with a child who is having a tantrum in the middle of the street and I’m like: oh I feel your pain. And I do feel that sympathy for the child that’s crying. I hate the sound of a child crying. It’s the worst sound in the world. I still go like a radar to that child anywhere in a five minute radius of me I will find them and I will zero in on them. And it’s so rewarding to be in that world and I get so much joy from it and I hope to have one more. We’ll see.

11. Not really. But I think the society puts a lot of pressure on being— there’s this whole term of good mothering. That should not be in a part of anybody’s dictionary. I think every mother does the best. Every mother is a good mother. There are sometimes there are circumstances which, you know, things happen, but I think every mother is a good mother.

12. Mom: I thought you did a great job of covering all the aspects of motherhood. I couldn’t think of anything else. First of all your openness, and you’re very warm and it’s easy to talk to you.

Daughter: I think your questions were open-ended enough that people could really tailor them to their own experiences. I think that’s important because there is no singular maternal experience. I think there’s things in common: how do you structure your time, always feeling interrupted, tired, whatever. But I spend too much time looking at mothers’ responses on the internet and sometimes I feel like they must be raising a different species and sometimes I feel completely recognized. So I think you did a good job of being able to include mothers with a lot of kids, one kid—

Another thing. I think it’s important. I was very stressed out when he was born about bonding. I was very worried that he would not bond with me and I think maybe one thing I would tell that lady in the elevator is like: don’t get in your head so much about what the research says it takes for a baby to bond with you. You’re the only mom he’s got and there’s a million ways to be a mother. So stop fretting about this chemical reaction that you have no control over anyway. I was so worried I was like, he won’t bond! And there wasn’t a competition to choose like who got to be his mom it was always going to be me. And I’ve only now started to get out of that mind set like I need to do something. Just being with him all the time is the bond.

13. I don’t know what question would have led to this— maybe it would have been about lessons learned— but one thing I’ve noticed about myself in my “parenting style” is that we all have baggage from our own parents, right? And so in an effort to not be your mom or your dad or whatever thing you don’t want to be like I feel like sometimes we have blind spots and we end up becoming the opposite thing which has it’s own risks but we don’t realize that. So for example my mom was really critical. She was constantly interfering with stuff even if it was like the simplest thing; I’m boiling water and she’s gonna come over and adjust the heat. So I feel like I’ve swung to the other extreme where I’m like, I’m not going to intervene at all because I don’t want you to feel micromanaged but then I’m like, well, I probably want to give you some boundaries so that you’re safe and so that you feel like you have proper advice and guidance in the world. So I feel like it’s been interesting for me to try to navigate that just because you’re not doing whatever it was your parents did that you didn’t particularly love, doesn’t mean— you gotta be careful to not do something equally as bad by trying to avoid it.

14. Did you ask what the hardest thing was? I feel like your questions got at that without being so direct. I think it’s a good set of questions because it’s open-ended enough that people can take it where they want.

I was super busy in work over the period of a couple of months in November through January. Too busy. And my younger son’s first birthday was in November. And I didn’t come down from work until it was like 7. Dinner was ready and it was time to eat and I had hardly seen him on his first birthday. I realize that birthdays are— it’s this arbitrary thing— if I see him the day before and the day after it’s not, you know, but I came down and I started crying. I was like I haven’t even seen my baby and it’s his first birthday and he’s the best baby ever and this is not what I signed up for. It wasn’t guilty as much as mad. I deserve to be with him on his first birthday but I had so much work and it’s client work that just needs to get done. So I had a little cry and I got over it. I was like, first of all, realizing that whether it’s yesterday or tomorrow really it’s not that big of a deal. Second of all, I have control over this I can scale down. And third of all, he feels loved and I’m a good mom and it’s okay; this is just one day and it’s okay to feel frustrated. So I talked myself off the ledge. It was a combination of feeling guilt and anger and frustration.

15. I think one of the things— I don’t know if there’s something you should have asked. I worked up until I gave birth and then I’ve been on a child care leave a little longer than expected. It’s a little lonely I think. Motherhood can be lonely. And it’s hard, when you get older, to make friends. You know what I mean? Bitch, I don’t have time to fucking make friends with you like we can’t brunch, do you know what I mean? But I think you have to just— I don’t know— it’s like a sink or swim type of job. You don’t know how you do it, you just do it. You know the movie Groundhog Day? It’s like the never ending day. From birth until— I don’t know— when will I relax? When they’re 40 or 80?

I’m going back to work in September and I have an au pair coming. I’m like one of those now. And I say that and I vomit in my mouth. If someone would have told me that like 10 years ago I’d be like, “I’m not going to have a fucking au pair.” But because of our hours I need it. And I’m worried. I think my kids are going to be fine; I think it’s me. My friend was here this weekend she was like, “it’s you. You’re kids will be fine. You’re going to be the mess. She’s like, watch, your kids will be fine.”

Everyone’s like: become a teacher! Your hours are great! Well what the heck do you do when you have to be at work and your kids have to be at school an hour and a half later? Because my start time is 7:43 at my new school. My kids don’t go to preschool until 9. I have to leave my house at 6 AM. My husband leaves the house at 6 AM.

One of the biggest things that I was worried about going back to work— you know when they have the little Thanksgiving stuff? I told my husband and I’m like I’m going to have to call your aunt to go or my mom might have to go or you might have to go into work late one day. I don’t want my kids to be the only kids without somebody there to love on them. My mom worked but she went back to work when I went to Kindergarten. She worked at a doctor’s office.

It’s hard. Women are expected to have a work life, have a home life, have a social life. And your kids and then this and then that. And it’s like when can we just sit and pick our toenails, you know? Seriously. I had no help when my kids were little; I didn’t have a nanny because I stayed at home— whatever. My husband would come home and I was like I’m gonna go and sit in the bathroom. He’s like, “oh, what are you gonna do? I just got home from work.” “I’m gonna fucking pick my toenails, that’s what I’m gonna do. You have no right to ask me what the fuck I’m going to do. You got to go and have adult conversations all day. I got to argue with a two and half year old.” So my husband comes home and he was like, “how was your day?” And I was like, “fuck you I want to sit and pick my fucking toenails for ten minutes. In peace!” And he’s like, “okay, okay go ahead.” And of course I know what’s going to happen— he’s not going to watch them. They’re banging on the door and I’m like, “can you just fucking take them on a walk around the building? I just want quiet.” And he’s like, “you okay? You look a little tense.” And I’m like, “fuck you.” He’s like, “well I worked all day” and I’m like, “I haven’t showered in like 4 days. Fuck off.” Do you know what I mean? I feel like sometimes it’s a competition of, like, who has a right to be more tired. I’m like, I haven’t washed my hair in 4 days and he’s like, well I don’t have any hair. I’m like, well that’s not my fault. Let me bathe? Can I bathe? Do you want a hug? Please let me bathe.

16. I don’t know if you were going to ask me more about parenting styles or how do you get through a day? What do you do to get through a day? How do you get through a day? Is it working out? Is it taking 20 minutes for yourself? What are the best tools you can use? Even if it’s not escaping, it’s just what do you need day to day to be who you want to be? Maybe it’s someone likes to go running for 20 minutes but maybe it’s reading to their kids for 15 minutes; maybe it’s quiet time with your kids. And maybe most of the time it will be without their children. Probably I just more look at it like it doesn’t feel like escaping to me like this helps me get through my day. I don’t know that I’m escaping necessarily my kids are right there. I can hear them. I have to give them breakfast and I have to be mindful of them so I wouldn’t call this an escape but this interaction helps me get through my day because it’s like I’m not just with them all day long.

17. You asked a lot of really good questions. I think when I think of motherhood and kind of the social constructs around it especially for suburban moms like, what’s interesting to me is kind of what grouping people pair themselves into. There’s the cliché of the granola, hippie attachment parent and then there’s a lot of parents, their identity of being a working mom. There’s a million things. I guess you could ask people, like, do you classify yourself as a particular kind of mom or if you had to what group or school would you be in?

I think I had kind of a gravitational pull towards attachment parenting but it felt like it didn’t work for who my kid was. Because, like, people would be like “just bring the baby into the bed with you” and I would complain that she wouldn’t sleep. And she never wanted to sleep next to us. Or people would be like “why don’t you just wear her?” I’m like because she’s not happy being worn either. I mean I did sometimes but it didn’t seem like there was any solution that was a catch-all for all my mom troubles and I also just feel like I don’t want to be part of some mom cliché.

If you find yourself in a group of moms that you’re not familiar with there’s certain topics of conversation that always inevitably come up and then people kind of, I dont know, it’s a weird push and pull because in one circumstance all the moms feel united in this common experience and they’re trying to relate to one another but then there’s a lot of defensiveness too. Like I was joking with my friend— I went to a birthday party of one of my husband’s friend’s kids who we haven’t seen in years and she has a very tight-knit group of moms from her daycare. And they were very supportive of one another but, as an outsider, it was very hard to break into it because they were like oh, you don’t work? And like I’ve known some mom groups where moms kind of almost adopt a bad moms attitude like almost like: I’m not going to be perfect; I’m going to literally joke about being the opposite of a good parent, which I find hard to relate to because to me so much of my day is thinking about motherhood, like it’s my job, you know? But then I don’t know. I wonder if that’s just me being judgmental. I have no idea.

It’s so interesting because dads don’t have that. They can just talk to other dads and have this commonality and make easy conversation where there’s no one’s feelings are being hurt and it’s not contentious at all. I feel like I have different groups of friends that are all really different and I can get along with them; like I don’t feel like I fit into any package in that way. Yeah, it’s interesting. I think some of it is rooted in people’s insecurities about motherhood, which everyone has, regardless of what kind of mom you are. But I happen to be friends with a lot of people who have multiple kids, like 3 or more kids, because my town is full of huge families and so people have a lot of questions: why did you decide to have one child? What is that like? There’s kind of a line of questions like: that must be so great, you have so much time to yourself. All moms are kind of always sizing each other up. I guess all women are. People think it’s so formative. Whereas you never assume that all people who have 2 kids have the same experience.

It’s nice talking about all this stuff because people don’t really discuss it honestly like this. I have a few good friends that I do talk about the emotional components of motherhood but yeah, everyone’s always kind of, they want to bond as moms but they don’t want to step on people’s toes because they don’t want to be offensive.

It’s interesting. I’ve met moms who are kind of emotionally distanced from their kids and I feel like that really more a manifestation of like trying to tolerate the circumstances they’re in which are horrific. Like people who have shared custody where they don’t see their kids every day. Or people that work so many hours that they’re not interacting with their kids on a daily basis. And I think any woman, and maybe this sounds sexist, but I think maybe it’s a traumatic experience and when that’s happening people have to blunt themselves to the emotions and they have to put a wall up. Because I’ve met moms like that. And I’m sure they are also talking about my psychology and why I act the way I act. It’s a really intense experience. It’s also like the most common experience so it’s hard to reconcile that.

I think in some ways postmodern-feminism has left out stay-at-home moms in a way that is not good for all moms. You know, being a mom is a form of work. Whether you’re kind of outsourcing that and you have a beloved nanny who is part of your family and is helping you mother or whether you’re doing it, it’s a devalued labor force, for sure.

18. Maybe if you could change anything about your parenting what would it be? Or what is something that you learned that you didn’t already know? For me, so something that I learned— something that shocked me— is when I went from one to two. I did not realize how much siblings impact one another. I thought it was just us and our parenting. I learned very quickly how my son is being shaped by his interactions with his older sister and that he’s not having the same experience that she had. And I thought that they would. They’re raised in the same house, they’ve been given the same things. I see how he gets quiet because she hogs up so much attention so he’s willing to take a backseat to his sister. It’s not just us that molds and I think that was surprising.

If I could change anything about my parenting: I think maybe not be so intense. I think I was following in my father’s footsteps and I’m very intense. But. I’m not so sure that I would change it; I think that I would just pay more attention to it. I would watch it more closely. The whole thing is that my husband is not very strict at all. He acts like he is but he’s not when it comes to discipline and actually doing things. As far as working and doing school work that’s all on me and pushing them. So I think also it depends on your partner. You can’t have two rocks— that’s not fair to them. I think I would work a little better to feed off of my partner to give them— and it’s all growing as a parent.

Regardless of the fact if I’m working or not I know the names of their best friends and dentists. So it’s not just an excuse about work. Mothers will know that no matter what is going on in their lives. Mothers are invested in their children on a different level. I think all fathers need to see that and ask them those questions. Ask them how their day was and who did they hang out with today. Just be more invested in their personality and what’s going on. It’s like they get to be oblivious and we kind of co-sign and we allow them to do that and we shouldn’t. I’m not trying to put them down at all. They’re needed. It’s just different.

19. How being a working mother has impacted my feelings on motherhood. As a working mom, I am very aware of the sacrifices that I have to make as a mom, but also of the benefits that I believe me and my children get from me working. People say that you can’t have it all, but I am trying to prove them wrong!

20. One question that someone asked me the other day was do you still hang out with your friends who don’t have kids? Which I thought was interesting. Or like how’s the relationship going? But there was a little bit of like— my friends’ reactions at the beginning. It was kind of weird. It was like happy but it was also like—bye— and now I think now that they think Oh! You’re still you.

21. I had no idea what questions you were going to ask.

22. Si me hubiero gustado tener otro hijo.

23. I don’t know. I feel like I think we talked about a lot because a lot of the questions you asked encompassed a lot of things. I’m sure a lot of people are the same way. These specific themes that run throughout based on their personality and lifestyle and what’s important to them. And so all these different questions will come up with the same themes because that’s just who they are and that’s just what they think about. I guess you could say what are you failing at? But you asked what does not come naturally to you which is probably a kinder way—

24. I don’t know I feel like— maybe what do you like the most or least about motherhood? But you kind of asked that. I was happy that you asked questions that tapped into my emotional well being than just basically about the baby. I feel like you had good questions.

26. I guess my favorite part is sort of like the most rewarding. But what’s my least favorite part? I guess it’s the same thing— I miss sleeping on my own schedule. The weekend loses all meaning when you have a baby who’s gonna wake up at the same time no matter what day of the week it is. You know?

27. I don’t know. I guess I didn’t really have— about motherhood— I wish I had something really important and clever to add. But I don’t. I guess just that when you get to my stage you miss having your children, your children in law, your grandchildren around and that’s a very hard part of arriving at this stage. And maybe I tend to look back with such, thank goodness, fondness of those times and they bring me a lot of joy even now. That’s the positive. The negative is missing it. The positive is having the memories which light up the day. One of the things I’m doing now is I’m going through boxes of old photographs and I’m sorting them to give to my children and they give me such pleasure because I relive those times.

Is it me or are these women just ridiculously smart and impressive and clever? Conducting these interviews was an incredible experience for me. Aside from having children and fulfilling that dream of being a mother, interviewing women about motherhood pretty much sums up every other dream I have: drinking coffee, hearing about people’s lives, commiserating about motherhood, helping people think about things they wouldn’t have otherweise thought about, bringing the stories of ordinary women into the universe. If I could do this all day, every day that would be my ideal life.

On that note, I’ve got my next set of questions burning a hole in my pocket. Anyone interested in this next round? Now that we know the entire world can be run through Zoom, it’ll be a lot easier to interview people on the other side of the globe. And a lot better for my aviophobia. Until next time.

Mom Talk – Part 13

Question: You’re in an elevator with your kids and a pregnant woman who says that she’s due with her first child in a week. She asks for your words of wisdom. You’re getting off at the next floor. What do you say?

I’m not great at thinking on my feet. If someone asked me this question I’d probably just exclaim something totally useless like “Oh wow! Congratulations! So exciting! It’s not easy, but you’ll be fine!” Then I’ll kick myself because I’ll have wanted to say:

Prepare for the unexpected. You literally never know what to expect with kids. There is no such thing as a plan because kids and life don’t follow plans. You can have a contingency plan when things don’t go the way you expected, which will be most of the time. But your contingency plan also won’t go the way you thought. Motherhood is a bunch of unknowns. It’s known unknowns (will your child be a good sleeper? Will you be a yeller?) It’s unknown unknowns (you never thought to consider whether you’d watch actual human poop come out of a runaway toddler). It’s unknown knowns (you don’t realize yet that you’ll recognize the difference between a tired cry and a wet diaper cry). The one thing it’s not is known knowns (you can be 100% confident of nothing.) You cannot know what this tiny being will be like, feel like, sound like, grow up to be like, grow up to look like, or anything else at all. All you can do is realize that and prepare yourself to face the smallest and the biggest obstacles.

Take care of your body. You’re not eating for two. Yes, you are growing a child. Yes, you may nurse a child. But that doesn’t give you free rein to eat anything and everything you want and crave. Exercise and eat well. If you’re not in the habit already, get into the habit now. It will not get easier as time goes on to develop healthy habits. Maybe after the first kid you’ll bounce right back to your pre-baby weight and shape but maybe not. And maybe the second or third time suddenly the weight won’t drop off and you’ll be pinching rolls in places you’d rather not. I wish someone had told me to take care of myself better or I wish that I had believed the people who tried to tell me. Trying to develop good habits now seems like an uphill battle— undoing the effects of every bagel and ice cream I just had to have. It would have been a lot easier to prevent seven years ago rather than repair after the fact.

I didn’t ask this question to the first few moms. One mom mentioned that she thought I’d ask for advice and I thought, yeah. That’s a good idea. It’s funny because moms tend to hate unsolicited advice (doesn’t everyone?) But if someone actually asked for it? Moms overwhelmingly find as many different ways to say: it will pass; it’s a phase; it’s hard for awhile, but things will get better; you will get through this. Moms also say: don’t be consumed by guilt; try to enjoy it; love your kids and embrace them for who they are; love your baby; it’s not how it seems on television and Instagram; there’s no one right way to do things; sleep; take care of yourself; trust your instincts; ignore unsolicited advice; know that you can never be fully prepared; realize that you’re not failing and that it’s hard for everyone.

The answers:

5. I would say just really enjoy it, don’t be too hard on yourself, just know that everything for better or worse is a phase and that no matter what happens— whether you nurse or do formula or the baby is colicky or not that all the baby really needs from you is to feel loved so just to show that to the baby and everything else will just fall into place.

6. At any step of this process it will pass. The feeling will pass. When I went to this mom group it started because we were all nursing our kids. It was a nursing mom thing. Some people had trouble and we would talk about some of the trouble we were having and the key words were: this too shall pass. This too shall pass. And I think that new moms always need to realize that. This is going to suck. It’s going to be amazing. All of it’s going to just keep going.

7. It’s a rough start but things will get better. That’s what I’d say. I’d say one other thing. I’d say in delivery just remember: do what’s best for the baby. And I say that all the time whenever I see a pregnant person because— and I don’t know if it’s as much of an issue here— but in the U.K. there was a big emphasis on natural birth. And everywhere you go people are, like, trying to drill into your head whatever you do you should have a natural birth and you should avoid any sort of drugs. And one of the things that I struggled with a lot after having my first is that it didn’t end up being a natural birth; it was an emergency C-section. And at the time one of the things that I regret about that, even in the moment when the doctors were like, “your child cannot breathe we have to take you into the theater” I was like, “no, it’s because you’re not letting me sit on the yoga ball and letting me move around the room; they told me in my antenatal classes I have to be able to walk and you gotta let me sit on the yoga ball.” And I look back at the time and think, how could I be so stupid? But it was because they drilled this idea into your head and you lost all perspective. I’m like, actually I just want to do what’s best for the baby. It’s probably not as big of an issue here. But in the U.K. any time I came across anyone that was pregnant my only advice was, just listen to what the doctors say. Because the other thing that they go on a lot about there is breastfeeding and, again, you have a lot of women who just can’t and the amount of guilt they’re ridden with— it’s very hard to recover from at a time when you’re already not particularly strong and you’re constantly beating yourself up about that fact that somebody told you you shouldn’t take an epidural, you shouldn’t have had a C-section and you should be breastfeeding as long as you can. Of course that’s the idea but if medically you can’t for some reason— it’s okay!

8. You will have your moment but try to enjoy the growth with your kid. The first two years might be really hard because you might feel like you’re a cow, literally, a pump machine but everything will become later on the achievement in life and you will enjoy more. So just hang in there and you will see the light at the end of the tunnel. That might be the thing I wish someone told me. I’d rather know. You and your husband won’t have a life but just hang in there. It will be better.

9. I’d tell her it’s going to be a little tough at first but then, they always change. So whatever hardship you’re struggling with, whether it’s reflux or lack of sleep— because that’s how you should go into pregnancy, is with the right expectation. It’s going to be a little tough but it always changes and always get better. I always say that to new moms.

10. I would tell her to not get consumed by guilt. I would tell her that there’s a lot of opportunities for mothers to feel guilty or bad about things and not to spend too much time in that world— to try to pull herself out of it. To just be present with her child. And just make the most of every moment with the child. Just to be present is so important. And just to enjoy the time with your child. Not to let that guilty voice go off in her head all the time. Just to live life. Be herself. Let her define being a mother for herself; don’t let other people tell her what her expectations should be or could be. Don’t let them put their expectations on you. Just be yourself. This is a small example but women have so much of that coming at them I feel. I feel as I get older they talk about things like, I think Gloria Steinam used to say, “you don’t understand what it’s like to be a woman in the working world until you’re actually in it and you’re being discriminated against and then you see it.” And she’s right. I found out I wasn’t paid the same as a lot of men in my field and it’s horrible.

I think that women have a lot of expectations put on them that aren’t really accurate or realistic from other people. I had a woman come up to me one time and say, “you’re small so you’re going to have a cesarean. You’re probably going to have one.” And I was like, “why would you say that?” and she was like, “well because you’re little and you know—” and to me the thought of a cesarean was not a great thought because I understood that it meant a lot of discomfort. And I know that’s okay, women have it, of course. But she immediately pegged me as someone who was going to need to have it. And my mother never had one and my mother was also petite. It has nothing to do with your outside body it has to do with your body internally.

So you get these people, they’re not even badly intentioned people. It’s not like the world is always mean. There can be plenty of people meaning to be kind or helpful but they’re not being helpful. So I think you have people coming to you with lots of thoughts and ideas about you and expectations about you that might not necessarily be accurate and I would just tell her to listen to her own voice and let her develop her own way of doing things and be a mother in her own right. And to kind of shake off the other stuff and just let it fall off of her and their expectations and their guilt and those things and just be herself. Just be herself. That’s all you can be. I think it’s hard to do. We all get caught up in it, and you do have to pull yourself back.

And also to tell her that it’s okay to take time— time out for herself without feeling badly about it. If she’s getting over stressed or over tired or burned out you do need a little bit of me time. And you just need to try to find ways to take it. Or say to your spouse or your significant other or whoever is on hand to help, you know, I need a few minutes. Just give me some breathing room. Just please cooperate with me and work with me and let me have my time so I can recharge myself.

I would also say not to get caught up in being perfect. There is no perfect. Just do things in a way that feels good and natural to her. I think that’s important.

11. Just to enjoy every moment. Don’t let one second slip away; it’s very precious. I think every day is beautiful but when I look back in those first few days are so good. I still miss, you know, kids touching you everywhere.

12. Mom: Enjoy every moment of it.* I feel with my daughter I wanted to go back to work and I kept wishing she would be older. Wishing— when she’s two or when she’s four or when she’s in preschool— and one of my biggest regrets is that I sort of wished away things waiting for something else to make life easier for us. So I would stop. Try to be more present in my life with my daughter and my husband.

What would you tell that lady?

Daughter: I’d probably give her my email address.

Mom: Say, “I’ll get back to you.”

Daughter: You know, for me it would be like: sing a lot, read a lot, remember that this baby is yours. He’s going to be like you and not like you in all the right and all the most annoying ways. And that eventually they sleep. Eventually they smile. And don’t be afraid to ask for help.

Mom: That’s a good one.

*I asked a follow-up question here: it’s something people say, “enjoy every moment” How do you respond to the idea that it is impossible to enjoy certain moments?

Mom: My perspective is looking back. When it was happening and she had a brain tumor and we were in the hospital for a month it’s hard to enjoy those moments or be present in those moments; you want to run away from those moments. Enjoy the moments that you can. When she’s playing or happy or you’re all well. I have a habit— I met someone once who does the same thing— of stopping at a certain time and saying: oh this is really a good moment. And I started it when she was about 7 and we were in Paris and we were walking. My husband was on one side and I was on the other and we were holding her hand and she was not quite seven in the summer and the weather was beautiful. And I started a habit which I do which is: I’m always going to remember this minute. And I have a whole list of them. Of consciously taking that. And I’m sorry I didn’t start it earlier than when she was almost 7. And those are the moments at night when I can’t sleep that I go back to: that walk in Paris, the Reber award- when she won the Reber award, her plays, my husband’s contacts in new york and having dinner with Norman Podhoretz at Commentary and meeting a Supreme Court Justice through my husband. These very special moments that I have because I consciously thought: I’m always going to remember this.

Daughter: I think that, to your question, you know, what about the moments you can’t enjoy? I think that there are moments that you have to survive but I prefer moments you endure. And those are moments you can look back on as moments of strength and that— you’re as a good mother in those moments that you endure as the ones where they’re so happy and they’re so successful and you feel very proud.

But there are other moments. So my friend gave me an example. She was holding her niece and she just cried for hours and there was not anything she could do. She didn’t know what was wrong. She said, “I just had to let her scream in my face for a few hours; and then at the end of the night my sister came home and said oh look there’s a tooth coming out.” She was teething. There wasn’t much they could have done to make that better. There are moments you just sort of have to endure and you’re not failing as a mother in those moments, you’re succeeding. Because you’re letting them feel their feelings. You’re letting them scream in your face which is, in a way, can be harder for you than it is for them to scream in your face. And that there are moments that you endure but those are valuable. They’re not enjoyable. They’re not moments you’ll replay. But to sort of bank them. You’re their mother because you let them scream in your face for hours and you can stand it. It means you love them even more than those who would just be like: oh it’s so much fun to be with you and then you cry— I can’t do anything for you! I’m handing you off. Although I’ve done that too. But I think there are moments you endure. They’re not worth nothing; they’re worth something.

13. I think I would say it’s been impressive to me how resilient kids are. It’s been impressive to me how much insight they have about themselves and maybe we don’t give them enough credit. I think given the unique circumstance of this situation, I don’t know if I can articulate this well, I feel like if we were a more traditional family you go into it believing that the harder you work at it the more perfect you can get it; but maybe because we were inherently given a “not perfect situation” it gave us the freedom to be okay with letting it be. Because of that it’s turned out awesome. In my mind it’s: recognize the boundaries of what you actually can control; try to have that recognition of what you can actually control. And since it’s such a small part of it, sometimes letting it be is allowing it to be as perfect as it can be.

I think if I thought this was going to be longer term then it would be harder to follow the advice that I’m giving myself right now. Then I would feel more compelled to nitpick over stuff that I know probably doesn’t make a difference but I think I wouldn’t be able to help myself. I almost feel like in some ways knowing that it’s transient allows me to have that perspective. To a fault of my own personality I think I would end up perseverating on stuff in retrospect—

Knowing that it’s temporary in theory should make it easier to not get attached but I feel like I’m already struggling with that. That hasn’t paid off or helped in the way that I hoped it would.

14. I would say that, you know, you’re never really prepared for everything that comes your way. Obviously its a good idea to educate yourself as much as possible and, you know, get different opinions on things. There’s no right way to do anything; there’s lots of opinions about the right way to do a million different things and you have to do what’s right for you and your family. You really, especially in the beginning, you have to go day by day. And to be honest I think there’s still a lot of that that happens with little kids. You make plans and you have to be prepared to change. I think flexibility is a huge thing with motherhood. You really can’t plan too much day to day.

15. Someone just told me their pregnant. She was like, “I don’t know if I’m ready for this.” And I was like, “you are!” and then I was like, “no! You’re not. No one ever is and that’s totally cool. You figure it out. It’s totally fine.” Honestly I wasn’t the type of pregnant person who read all the books, which is funny because I am sort of type A so you’d think I was trying to be fully prepared. I think I was just trying to roll with the punches about it and I feel like that served me, at least my personality, because rather than feeling like I had some expectations that needed to be fulfilled that then became a source of anxiety or something it was just like: here’s a baby.

Acutally some of the words of advice that are so simple but I’ve taken them with me – when my first was getting discharged from the NICU— he was early so he was in the NICU for 3 weeks— he was fine and is fine thankfully. But the doctor, his overseeing doctor in the NICU said as we’re literally getting strolled out of the hospital was like, “feed him and love him that’s all you gotta do. Feed him and love him.” and I was like that’s so good; it’s so simple. you don’t have to worry about them doing things on a timeline. People would be like, “oh, they’re 9 months old but they’re not—” and I’m like he’s not going to be 12 years old and not walking. It’s fine. It’s fine.

So anyway words of advice: feed him and love him, I guess. It was just so pure and simple from the doctor. I don’t have stringent views on parenthood whether you should breastfeed or formula feed or sleep train or not sleep train. For me it’s like you do what works for you. If that’s being super regimented, cool. If it’s not at all, cool. I know that’s like a movement to support all mothers which I agree with but I think it’s also just, to me, it’s like practical reality. Everybody’s doing their best. You’ll figure it out. Take care of him. Don’t be an asshole.

I do like being informed. I like knowing all the things, all of the options, what’s the right thing to do? Because that’s the other thing: I’m not an expert in this; someone else is. I do have views that I adhere to in terms of like, I’ll go to a website and if it’s like “How to Be an Authoritarian Parent” that’s not going to be my jam, right? But there’s one called Hand In Hand Parenting and I sometimes find their articles helpful in terms of things like how to handle outbursts or something. And I ask my pediatrician a lot of questions and sometimes I agree with what he says and sometimes I’m like I’m not gonna do that.

16. Trust your instinct. You’re the mom. Do what you think is right. I’m not going to say, like, “do this or go buy that” I think you gotta learn it. You can do it. I think that’s something people don’t say especially nowadays with social media and Google, right? There’s a plethora of knowledge out there and moms are always being questioned. “Why are you doing that? We never did that with you guys when you were younger—” Well you know what Brenda, who fucking asked you? Nobody asked you. You know, people feel very free and liberated to give their opinions to people when they’re not asked for. If somebody asks me— if I don’t know a person: hey you know what, you’re going to do a great job. You’re going to love that baby. Love your baby. Do what you think is the right thing. Because how the fuck do I know? Every kid is different. There’s no formula for raising kids. There’s no right or wrong way it’s just different. I think building up the moms. Stop making moms question everything, right? I feel like my mom’s generation I feel like they were tougher. They were tougher. They didn’t have, like, oh let me check to make sure she’s getting enough calcium or whatever. I was like, eh, have some chocolate milk you’ll live. I mean we all lived. We didn’t have fucking car seats. How am I still here? I didn’t have a car seat! My parents put me in a seat belt but I’ve been in cars with my friends when I was a kid and they didn’t even fucking put the seat belt on us. Or you go to the park and you’re standing on the swing and you try to purposely flip over? I mean the fact that I’m alive— The shit that we did. I mean I did some sketchy shit as a kid. If my fucking kids ever did it— I would chain them to the door handle and be like now you’re going nowhere. I know they’ll never get away with it. I know what goes on.

17. I would say my words of wisdom would be: it’s really, really hard and don’t feel bad that it’s really hard. Don’t feel like you’re failing because it’s really hard. It’s just really hard in the very beginning. I mean it’s hard the whole time but that to me was the biggest. I wish someone had just said to me: you’re going to feel like a failure and a mess the first few weeks because it’s so hard but everyone feels that way. Nobody told me that. I wish. I would have felt so much better if someone had said to me: the way you feel right now, that you feel so defeated— but no one said that to me. I would have said it’s really hard but it gets so much easier but don’t feel like a failure because I felt like a failure and like a terrible mother because it felt so hard to me. That’s what I would say. I would not give them fluff. I would just be like it’s okay to feel that way. It’s going to get better but it’s going to be really hard and you’re going to be fine. That baby’s going to make you crazy for months. You are literally going to have another human being attached to your body for months and you are just going to be a mess and it’s okay.

18. I tend to always give people advice about sleep because for me that was so formative in my early motherhood that I tell people just, I know it’s cliche people say try to sleep when your kid is sleeping and of course you don’t want to you want to do all the house errands and have time for yourself but sleep is really important for mental health so make sure you get it somehow. Ask for help so that you can sleep.

19. No one will know your children the way you know them and trust your maternal instincts. It’s God-given. I believe in it; don’t talk yourself out of it. Trust those maternal instincts more than anything else.

20. To be present in every moment with her children and to enjoy every minute because it goes by so quickly.

21. Enjoy it. You’re so like, “this is hard, this is hard, this is hard” and then it’s gone. Like the stage where he couldn’t go anywhere and was just sleeping and snuggling was so fast but it felt so intense. So yeah. I would just say enjoy it and be present. And I think people gave me that advice but I don’t think there’s any other advice that you could give someone that’s helpful. Maybe readjust your expectations.

22. I would absolutely say what I’ve said to my sister: there’s more than one way to do things. That’s my advice. There’s no right or wrong. Even a mundane thing like putting a diaper on. Or when your kids get older you just do your best. I’ve said that to many a person. Because otherwise you put yourself under too much pressure: oh I should be doing this I should be doing that or, “my husband, I can’t leave him with the baby because he doesn’t know what to do—” because there’s more than one way to do things.

23. Decirle que encomiende su hijo a Dios.

24. Go with your gut. Because I think that was really helpful for me when I was recognizing you can just listen to yourself not in an arrogant, close-minded sort of way but just trust yourself. My best friend told me that and I think that was valuable. Trust yourself. You know what feels right for you. And I think so many moms don’t because there is so much information and everyone does things so differently and it’s so confusing. Once you take that in as something that you should be doing versus another option it gets really overwhelming. Go with your gut and make time for yourself even though it seems so impossible and downright selfish make time for yourself whatever that is. For me it’s to exercise but some people it’s like shop, nails, whatever works I guess. But I’d say trust yourself and make time for yourself.

25. I would say, basically, don’t worry about what everybody else is telling you: other older women in your life or even your other mom friends, like, advice or what you should or shouldn’t be doing because you’re going to know your baby very quickly. Whether or not you recognize it. And if you’re really scared, call the pediatrician because they don’t care. But yeah that was the most irritating thing for me was hearing from parents and grandparents and even neighbors who have kids who are already teenagers or whatever hearing like, “oh, when my son or my daughter— we tried this—” Just don’t. I don’t want to hear the suggestions. I appreciate it, but if I really need some help I’ll call the doctor. That kind of stuff. That’s me personally. Drove me nuts more than anything else. That and I’d also probably tell her about her nipples because nobody told me. If no one’s told you yet: breastfeeding is really hard. And I would tell her to download the Tiny Beans app which has been a savior for us. It’s basically like baby Facbeook kind of. It works wonderfully.

26. Nothing will ever go exactly as you want it to so don’t expect that. And enjoy the moments because although it sounds trite and some of the days are years you have to enjoy them even—I don’t know— even the chaos and the crazy feelings and try to take a step back every now and again to appreciate it.

27. Try not to worry too much. That’s me, what can I tell you? And realize how lucky you are to have this time of life and remember that it doesn’t last as long as it feels that it’s lasting. That’s the other thing you feel that every minute— every stage is going to last forever when they’re little and it really doesn’t.

Coming up: Mom Talk – part 14 – What didn’t I ask you?

Mom Talk – Part 1

If it’s better for you to listen to this while you – do the dishes or something – or you just really want to hear my soothing voice (and bonus butchering of Spanish pronunciation in answer 23!) – here’s the audio:

About a year ago I decided to write a book. At the time I was in a reading phase – this is the reality of my life after children. I don’t have enough free time to do all the things I want and I have absolutely no balance in my life. Instead I go through phases where, in my free time, I focus every ounce of energy and attention on one particular thing. I spend my free time binging television and binging authors and binging social media. Or I’ll decide to learn a skill and I’ll spend every free second learning it. For about a month and then I’m onto the next thing.

About a year ago – well – I wasn’t so much in a reading phase as I was in a spend-all-my-free-time-buying-books-I-may-or-may-not-end-up-reading-phase. So there I was buying books. I bought a whole bunch of books about women because I think women are pretty cool and because I tend to be drawn to books about people – books that tell about people’s lives. But is it me? I’ve noticed that books about people tend to be about famous people or outstanding people. Notable people. Exceptional people. People whose lives are exceptionally hard or exceptionally blessed or people who are exceptionally well-known.

So after seeing and purchasing some books featuring the fairly exceptional lives of fairly exceptional women I decided what I wanted out there in the world was a book about regular women (who, it turns out, happen to be exceptional.) I thought about the majority of the women in my life and realized that one thing they all had in common was motherhood. So I emailed about a hundred women I could think of off the top of my head asking if anyone would be interested in talking to me about motherhood. The women I know aren’t extraordinary in the world. But their experiences and their perspectives are interesting and worthwhile and valuable. They are interesting and inspiring. Not only that, but they’re relatable. And then came the next phase of my life: furiously interviewing, recording, transcribing and figuring out how to publish (self-publish?) in a world completely over-saturated with people who think they have something unique to say and who think their words are worth sharing.

My progress halted with the beginning of summer and really didn’t pick up again until the beginning of 2020 when I decided it was time to get my sh*t together. I finished formatting what I had written and compiled so far but there were two more interviews left to do. As soon as I had done those and added them to the book I was ready to get a proof printed and I would be off to the races. And then very suddenly Coronavirus became a thing. Then we were quarantined.

I’ve spent the past 3 weeks alternating between being such a good mother I deserve awards for my patience, creativity, and making the most out of a terrible and scary situation and literally the kind of mother who should be reported to DYFS. I am happy and sad and scared and bored and frustrated and grateful. I miss my life. I miss my friends. I miss my time. At the same time I feel incredibly guilty for feeling any way that isn’t grateful – for food, shelter, health, time with my family, and the technology to be able to keep up with my kids’ education. And I am grateful. But I am also all of those other things. The one thing that keeps me remotely sane aside from lots of coffee and wine is knowing that although I’m isolated, I’m not alone.

I originally envisioned my book as a collection of feature stories— a photo and an interview for every mom I spoke to because that’s what the books I bought looked like. Clearly a good format— why mess with that? But, as with many things, the process of conducting the interviews, transcribing them, and reviewing them took me somewhere else. I realized that it wasn’t the individual story that mattered most. It was the universality of the answers. I don’t think the women I spoke to represent all mothers— not by a long-shot. There are hundreds of millions of moms in the world and this is a sample of 27. There are moms of every race, religion, class, and every demographic distinction in every corner of the world and I’m not crazy (dumb?) enough to think that the moms in this book speak for all moms. But. But these moms speak to the universalities of motherhood. Within these pages there are mothers of infants, preschoolers, tweens, teenagers, and adults. There are mothers of 1 child and mothers of 4. There are mothers who grew up in this country and out. There are working mothers and stay-at-home mothers. One mom is a foster mother. One mom is a widow. Maybe these moms don’t speak for all moms; maybe they only speak for themselves. Their experiences are worth knowing because their lives are meaningful.

In this new reality in which our motherhood is something we cannot escape even for a moment and in which we are so very much not alone and yet so very lonely I think it is more important than ever to feel united with all the other mothers. I’ve decided to scrap the book idea or maybe to come back to it another time. For now, I decided to publish each of the chapters one by one. I sort of hope it starts a conversation about motherhood. I like conversations. I like mothers. So there you go.

So what is it about moms that I find so interesting? Why are moms so amazing? Moms spend a lot of time thinking about their kids and they spend a lot of time thinking about their families as a whole. They think about meals and doctors and school and activities and camps. They think about in-laws and parents. They think about school project storage and backyard play sets and birthday parties. They think about the differences among diapers and rashes and travel potties. They think about friends and holidays and Elves on Shelves. They even, sometimes, think about themselves. But they don’t usually think about their identity as a mother, even though once you are a mother, you can never not be one. And they don’t usually think about it because they’re usually never asked.

When you ask a mom questions about motherhood she tells you fascinating things. When you ask 27 moms questions about their motherhood you begin to see some trends. There are some questions with 27 different answers and some questions with 27 versions of the same answer. There is a “world of moms” as one of the moms put it, and once you’re in it, you never leave. It sounds a little drastic— well it is drastic. Motherhood never ends. It’s obvious except no one really thinks about it. No one really thinks about a lot about motherhood.

Motherhood as portrayed in movies and television and motherhood as portrayed on social media might as well be motherhood as portrayed on Mars as compared to the reality of being a mother. Ask yourself: what do you miss from before you had kids? You’re not a bad person to miss the life before. Ask your partner: what do you wish you had known about motherhood? Chances are the life she’s living is different from the one she expected. Every mother has a story that’s unique and at the same time that story unites her to every other mother that has ever been and will ever be.

What does not come naturally to moms? Turns out a lot. But let’s put breastfeeding at the top of the list. Are moms happy? Depends. What’s something moms miss? Freedom and the ability to jump without peeing, among other things. Most of these moms had never been asked questions like these before and, as it happens, they all had a lot to say.

In the end I divided the book up by question with all the answers to that question grouped together. The numbers stay consistent so that the mom who is answer number 1 for the first question is answer number 1 the whole way through. You may notice there are some questions for which one or more of the numbers are absent. In the case where only one number is missing: I forgot to ask the question (I’m human!) In the only case where multiple numbers are missing (question 13) it’s because I didn’t originally have this question as part of my set. I got the idea to ask it during the third interview and included it starting at interview number 5.

I included every “like” and every “um”and tried to the best of my ability to convey tone through punctuation and italics. One thing that doesn’t come through is the laughter – so much laughter. I have removed or changed names and place names but otherwise have not changed the words of the women at all.

I didn’t originally visualize this as advice, but now that it’s done I see the value in these stories for moms-to-be. I didn’t visualize this as a bitch-fest, but, yeah, now I can see this as a sort of commiseration book for all moms. I don’t know if I thought non-moms would be interested in this but, as it turns out, yes. I think this would be an illuminating book for partners of moms and all non-moms.

Question 1: What is one word you would use to describe motherhood?

Motherhood is complicated. To me, there’s nothing about motherhood that doesn’t bring up conflicting and yet equally valid feelings. Every question, every decision. What, how, and when to feed them. How, when, and where to get them to go to sleep. How, with what method, with how much force and flexibility to discipline them. What I thought were gut feelings turn out to be changeable (and possibly indigestion.)

Being a mother is complicated. I want to give my kids everything but not spoil them. I want to squeeze them and hug them and kiss them for days and sometimes I don’t want them to touch me. They are like me in ways that make me happy and they are like me in ways that drive me crazy.

My kids have fulfilled my longest, most enduring life-long dream but sometimes I’m overwhelmed and I question my ability to do any of this.

​I know I’m not alone. I know this because so many of the answers below touch on the equal yet opposite, conflicting yet not mutually exclusive feelings that become a part of the everyday motherhood experience: overwhelming, life-changing, never-ending, fucking hard, challenging, shitty, wonderful, selflessness, enriching, sacrifice, encompassing, all-encompassing, fluid, adapting, rewarding, responsibility, strength, multi-tasking, love, happiness, beautiful, roller-coaster, crazy, unanticipated, expanding, expansive, insane, hard, intense, consuming, fulfilling, emotional, great, tiring, problem-solving, scary.

1. One word? Let me think. I don’t know if it should be positive or negative. I’m a negative person so— overwhelming? Let me think harder, hold on.

I like this one: never-ending. Challenging. I like this even better: life-changing. That’s mine. Because it’s not positive or negative. Life-changing. Some ways positive some ways negative.

2. Can it be a phrase? Fucking hard.

3. Shitty. No, I’m just kidding. It’s wonderful. Motherhood. It is— God, one word? Dammit. Motherhood. It is selflessness. But not always. I mean, my kids would love it if I didn’t work, but that’s what’s best for me which, in the end, is also what’s best for them. Because, to me, I’m not working because it’s, like, a hobby I want. It’s not a selfish decision. It’s something that fulfills me and therefore lets me be happier for them and not resent them. Do you know what I mean? But I do think good parenting— good motherhood— is being selfless.

4. Enriching. My entire life is different than the day before my daughter was born and maybe I would say for the first month I didn’t realize what a change it was for the better. Then everything since then has more color and more purpose and more meaning. My work is to support my family and I’m so much more motivated. To educate my children is a driving factor. My politics are so much more about them and people like them. My volunteer work is creating community for the future so I can hand off what I received as a gift even, hopefully, better. And that’s all because of motherhood. That whole lens and that whole filter is all because of my kids.

5. I’m wavering between encompassing and all-encompassing. I feel like all-encompassing means it consumes my whole life, which it doesn’t consume my whole life; I have a lot of things outside of motherhood. But I actually feel like me being a mom is the biggest part of me that somehow gets ingrained in everything else that I do. For better or for worse. I work, but I make arrangements at work so that I can be a good mom, too. So I would say all-encompassing. As long as it doesn’t make me sound like it takes over my whole life. Like, I really feel like I have a life. But I just feel like I am a mom and in that life I have to— your life is different when you’re a mom. Like, I go out with my husband or go away for the weekend but then you need childcare. Whatever you do it’s somehow attached to your kids.

6. Wow. There’s so many things going on in my mind, I can’t pick a word. Fluid. So I think that motherhood comes in many different forms. If we’re talking about the act of motherhood, I mean, I think it’s pretty clear. What you’re trying to do is raise good humans. But the way that mothers are mothers is totally different depending on personal desires this time, in the future or the stage or the life of your kids. Sometimes you’re more involved; sometimes you’re less involved. Sometimes you’re more in tune; sometimes you’re less in tune. You just kind of have to keep adapting to the changing tides as a mother to help your kids grow.​

7. I guess if I had to use one word I would use the word enriching and I guess the reason I would use that word is because I think— I mean the first word that comes to mind is certainly challenging and I think that’s because, of all the things I’ve done throughout the course of my life, this is probably the most challenging thing I’ve done but also the most rewarding. And I think I’ve grown in ways and in time frames that I didn’t think were possible. The growth I think that you experience in that first month of motherhood is something that I think is unmatched; you can’t compare that to experiences at college or, you know, in your first job. I think that, you know, learning to sacrifice, learning to block out all the noise around you and really think about what’s best for your child and to trust your gut— and to do all of that in the midst of lack of sleep, lack of clarity, your body is recovering, you’re in pain and the hormonal issues. Then I think taking that out further— each stage of their life they’re constantly growing so I think the challenge keeps changing and you keep responding to that challenge in a different way. And I think it’s amazing to grow together and then at the end of that sort of work on the next thing. I think the whole thing is a very enriching experience. And the love you feel for your child is obviously one that’s unmatched; so your dedication to being a mother— you can’t really compare that to anything else.​

8. One word? Well the first word came to my mind was responsibility. I think it’s nice that we have nine months to process become mother because before 30 I don’t really want kid because I don’t know how to handle them. I love other people’s kid but I really don’t know how to handle mine. And then took, you know, nine months. Even when my daughter was born I was like, who is this? She’s so strange. But I’m the mother now; I need to be able to take care of her, you know, not break her, and she needs to be alive. Later on what kind of person she will grow into? So it’s all responsibility came to mind first.

Then also they help you grow. You’re not sure what kind of mother you are; you sort of grow with them. There’s no book, no person to show you how to become a mother. You just figure it out as time goes by. They also have responsibility themselves, too. They’re the kid and they don’t know about it but you know they are helping you to learn more about yourself. They help you grow.

9. Strength. I think as a kid I was always like the big kid with the little kids. I loved babysitting and I loved playing and I loved being around children and I always knew I wanted to be a mom but obviously most kids don’t appreciate what it actually takes to be a mom. So I find that in my life, to be the best mom that I can be, and also just to be the most well-rounded person I can be— I think to be a really good mom you have to be a very well-rounded mom and it takes a lot of strength to get there. Strength encompasses so many other words to me. What does strength mean to me? It’s pushing through schedules and multi-tasking and being organized and being present and being, you know, happy, and all of that requires a lot of strength. Does that make sense?​

10. Love. It’s such a deep love. When I got pregnant, I didn’t know I was pregnant for a long time. I didn’t actually find out I was pregnant until I was somewhat far along. When I first heard the words, “You’re pregnant” I was so happy because I knew it was going to be an opportunity to love another human being in a way I never had before, being a first time mom. So I think that the essence of motherhood is about a deep love for your child. And nurturing. And kindness. I think it’s all kind of bundled up in love.

11. Happiness. Like nothing has ever made me any happier than the whole thing about giving birth to both my kids and raising them.​

12. Mom: Just one, huh? For me, it was beautiful.

Daughter: Roller-coaster.

Mom: Because I’m looking back, so my perspective is very different than yours would be. I haven’t been involved in it in so many years. So I look back on the experience. Life-changing.

Daughter: The way I described it to people, particularly in the first month, which was— really crazy— compared to like now, when I’m starting to get to know his habits. At the beginning that the highs are really high and the lows are really low. So when he smiles at you for the first time there’s no feeling as rewarding and as life-affirming as that. But when it’s 3 AM and he’s crying and you don’t know why you’re just like— you can’t. It’s hard to keep perspective about: this will pass. In that moment you think: this is never going to stop. In that way it’s a roller-coaster. But I have to say that’s really the newborn phase. Now it’s just working around— deciding when I want to live under a sleeping baby 8 hours a day. Which, again, is super fun and maybe not sustainable. So figuring out his habits and trying to create a schedule for us. So it’s a little less roller-coaster.

13. I would have said unanticipated. Not unanticipated the experience— yes we anticipated the experience for a long time— but just the way I feel about a lot of stuff isn’t at all what I thought. Like the stuff that I thought would be hard, some of it is a lot easier; and the stuff that I thought would be easy— I find myself constantly thinking through things that I’ve never even given a second thought to before. Or like having attachment to someone you hardly know— I never anticipated that. There’s just so many elements of it that I would never have considered as part of the process.

14. Challenging.

15. I think I would go with expansive. I feel like motherhood expands— or I can speak for myself— has expanded my perspective on what’s important, what’s difficult, what is meaningful and also has really just really just expanded my— and the reason I say expansive— it multiplies my sense of love. I’m sure you’ve heard the thing that having a second child or a third child— it’s not that your heart gets split, it gets multiplied? So I feel like that’s what I mean by expansive. If I come up with another better word I’ll let you know.

I think also it makes your life so much bigger in all of the ways that having a bigger life— it’s more to do, more to coordinate, more to love, more to go crazy over. So bigger. Expansive. Or expanding. I’ll think about it.

​16. Can I take a minute? One word? That’s one of the hardest questions I think I’ve ever been asked because there’s so many things that go into it. So I’m trying to encompass the whole thing without sounding, like, “oh, it’s wonderful!” and then sounding like, “oh my God, it’s insane!” I’m going to maybe say insane. Because that can be both good and bad. Insanely wonderful and insanely challenging at the same time. So let’s go with insane.​

17. Hard. Hardest thing I’ve ever done in my entire life. For me, I had a very good handle on my career and my life. I’m very organized and I thought I was ready and anticipated what it would be and I was not at all. Not for handling and taking care of a kid but for how much my life was going to change and how I’ll never be that same person again. It really threw me for a loop.

18. One word. Intense. It’s a really intense dynamic and not just I think because I have one child. I think that makes it even more intense, but just in general, the amount of love that you have for a child is the most intense thing that you’ll ever experience.

19. I know the word I want to say but I can’t think of what it is. Consuming.

20. Fulfilling.

21. I think roller-coaster. Have you heard that one before? I think it’s like emotional. I was really surprised by the baby blues or whatever— like the joy and the sadness. All of that. And then I think also you can be sweating when the baby’s crying and your heart starts racing and you’re like, oh my God I have to fix this and then it’s over and then you’re like, oh now you’re smiling! So cute! It’s just moment to moment and unpredictable. Every day is different. That’s the infant stage and I’m sure it only gets more intense when he’s like, “Mom what do I say to the bully at school?” Or “why did I hear this on the TV?” So I’m sure it’s going to get crazier.

22. Great. It’s a great thing to have kids. It’s a problem at times. There’s definitely problems. It’s definitely hard at times; but generally speaking I think it’s great.

23. Realización​

24. The first word that comes to my brain is tiring but that’s not fair to me or my kids. But then my second is probably challenge, but not like challenging in a bad way but just actually: this is a challenge. And then problem-solving. I feel like I’ve never problem-solved more in my whole life. It’s like a puzzle. Like this has happened before. Last time it worked really well when I did blah blah blah; this time I didn’t do that and it’s not going that well or I’m in a different mood or whatever. It’s a lot of: how can I approach this so that we get the outcome that’s best for both me— and I often talk about my daughter because my son is still a baby— but in terms of the mental— how do I make it so that she’s not having a tantrum? Or we’re on the precipice of like she’s gonna yell at me and I’m gonna yell at her or I can diffuse this in a way that everyone’s happy. But yeah. That’s something that I like and that comes to me pretty naturally.

25. Scary. Yeah. It was literally the first word that popped into my head. One— everything that’s out there now— all those true crime dramas and everything that just terrifies me— the future—the potential—these awful morbid thoughts about how I can’t protect them in the future. And also scary just like— this is going to sound horrible— protecting them from myself. I want to make sure I’m not damaging them emotionally. Everything that they exhibit from such early ages like how— a few weeks ago— I thought I was putting on a really good face with postpartum or just exhaustion and when my older daughter said to me, “oh, Mommy’s happy today!” That was so sad. I’m just scared I’m not going to be able to hide if I am sad. Like she shouldn’t be picking up on that. It should always be that I’m happy with her— that I’m invested in her and not in myself. So that’s scary.

26. In this moment? Um. That’s an interesting question. I have about six, seven things running through my head. I don’t think it’s fair to just say one of them. So my words: Is all-encompassing—does that count as one? Wonderful. Amazing. Confusing. Chaotic. I might come back if I think of something else. That’s my short list.

27. Complicated. The best time in the world and in some ways the most daunting. I’ll put it that way. 

Dear Mama Mader

Dear Mama Mader:

My 10 month old is starting to refuse his 2nd nap. He goes down for his first nap about 2.5-3 hours after he wakes up in the morning but for his second nap he just refuses to sleep, sometimes staying awake in his crib for an hour or more. Isn’t he too young to only have one nap? 

-one nap wonder

Good question. What is it with babies and toddlers?  They need inordinate amounts of sleep and yet they fight it again and again.  What’s the deal with that?

After 4 babies you might think I’d have *the* perfect answer to this question.  Well I do have the answer but it’s that frustrating answer that isn’t really an answer it’s just the standard thing you say about anything related to babies – here it is – here’s the magic – there is no right or wrong answer because every baby is different.  Newborns generally sleep for 15 or 16 hours in any 24 hour period. Tell that to the parents with the colicky baby who just won’t stop crying. Mayo Clinic tells me that most 3-4 month olds are able to sleep for 5 hour stretches but out of my 4 children zero managed to check that box.

With naps it’s the same.  Some babies go from napping throughout the day to 3 naps to 2 and by one year or so start taking just 1 longer (2-3 hour) nap during the day (according to the pediatrician). Well my daughter didn’t nap well at all – maybe I’d get 30 minutes a couple of times a day. My first son was better but still – where were the 3 hour naps I was promised? He continued to take two 1-1.5 hour naps every day well past a year and my second son did the same.  Finally, like a very considerate third child, he took 2 naps a day – the first was shorter and one second lasted 3 hours at least. He continued with 2 naps until he was 18 months old. He just needed them. And with number 4 we’re back to two shorter naps like his sister.  Combining two short naps into one nap doesn’t always make for a longer nap – just the same short nap and a cranky baby.  We tried with #4 and it just didn’t work for him so two short naps it is. My point is every kid is different.  Sometimes it doesn’t matter that the doctor says switch to 1 nap at a year because the doctor isn’t home with you staring at the monitor as the baby sits in his crib for 2 hours instead of sleeping. If you want to transition him to one nap I would suggest doing the following:

  1. Slowly push his nap back so that it’s around 11 or 12 (eventually you may want to push it even later (1 or 1:30) so that it won’t interfere with activities and nursery school).
  2. Start the bedtime routine a bit earlier if you can.  If your baby currently has a 7:30 bedtime 6:30 may work better, at least until he gets used to the new schedule and then you can slowly push it later again.

Bedtime is hard as are most topics related to children because there are always multiple factors to consider.  An earlier bedtime might mean the baby won’t get to see one or both of his parents before bed. A later bedtime might make for a tired and cranky baby.  You have to do what’s best for the baby even if it isn’t always the option that seems desirable. If the little one is yawning and rubbing his eyes at 6, then he should go to bed at 6 even if Mommy or Daddy isn’t home yet.

As for naps, and to answer your question a bit more concisely (I realize it’s too late for that), he’s not too young to have only one nap.  He is his own little person and if you follow his cues he will fall into the schedule that is right for him.  If you try to push to one nap and it backfires you can always go back to the drawing board.

-Mama Mader

What do you think, dear readers? What tips do you have? Can a baby this young give up the second nap?

Looking for sage wisdom on all of your parenting, marriage, etiquette or life questions? Send ’em my way!

Coming up tomorrow – Manners by Mama – guide to visiting people with kids